By Eliana Ituarte Strömberg
Scandinavian countries are routinely held up as a model of clean energy and high quality of life. This article examines that picture, drawing on three interviews — with a Sri Lankan human-rights lawyer, a Colombian lawyer-anthropologist, and a Norwegian engineer — alongside published data on emissions, deforestation and energy use, to ask what “green” really means once historical responsibility, biodiversity loss and overconsumption are brought into the frame.

Voices behind the report
This article draws on online research and three interviews: Neshan Gunasekera, a Sri Lankan lawyer working on human rights and environmental governance; Valentina Lomanto, a Colombian lawyer and anthropologist; and Ellef Hersoug, a Norwegian engineer. Their perspectives — from human rights, indigenous and community law, and engineering — frame the analysis that follows.
Industrialisation, deforestation and the question of biodiversity
There is a common assumption that if developing countries follow the same industrial path as today’s developed economies, they will reach the same outcomes. What this framing overlooks is the biodiversity that was lost along the way. Norway’s nineteenth-century industrial expansion — particularly in timber and wood-pulp — produced economic growth but also large-scale forest clearance, the long-term consequences of which are still visible in the country’s emissions accounts today.[1]
Contemporary figures complete the picture. According to the Norwegian Institute of Bioeconomy Research (NIBIO), Norway loses roughly the equivalent of one football pitch of forest every hour — amounting in 2015 to deforestation emissions of about 2.6 million tonnes of CO₂, equivalent to roughly twice the country’s emissions from domestic air traffic that year.[2] In Sweden, a Lund University study found that almost a quarter of the country’s remaining unprotected old-growth forest was logged between 2003 and 2019.[3] These are not legacy numbers from a distant industrial era; they are recent.
Who pollutes, and who pays the price
Scandinavian countries also have historically high per-capita CO₂ emissions — substantially higher than the global average.[4] The countries facing the most severe climate impacts, however, are largely those with the smallest carbon footprints and least economic resilience: South Sudan, Somalia and Chad consistently appear among the world’s poorest and most climate-vulnerable states.[5] The asymmetry is structural rather than incidental, and it is the basis on which developed states have, under Article 8 of the Paris Agreement and the Loss and Damage Fund agreed at COP27, accepted a responsibility to provide finance and support for climate-related loss and damage in developing countries.[6]
Where to start
Norwegian engineer Ellef Hersoug suggests that one of the most concrete first steps is collaboration between younger engineers from Scandinavian and developing countries on renewable-energy projects — of the kind that initiatives such as Engineers Without Borders are designed to facilitate.
Neshan Gunasekera offers a different starting point. In many developing countries, primary forests — dense with biodiversity — can be bought for prices that bear no relation to their ecological value. Once a primary forest is cleared, full restoration is effectively impossible: the soil structure, the inter-species relationships and the carbon-sequestration capacity of an old-growth ecosystem cannot be reproduced by replanting. To value such ecosystems purely in market terms is therefore to mis-price them by orders of magnitude.
The deeper problem and SDG 7: clean energy alone is not enough
SDG 7 (Affordable and Clean Energy) is often interpreted as a straightforward technological target: install more wind turbines and solar panels, replace fossil fuels, count tonnes of CO₂ avoided. The data complicates this. High-income countries currently use roughly fifty times more energy per capita than low-income countries and emit on the order of twenty times more transport-related CO₂ per person.[7] Building enough renewable capacity to sustain that level of consumption — globally and indefinitely — runs into a different problem. Wind turbines, solar panels and electric-vehicle batteries depend on rare-earth minerals such as cobalt, nickel and lithium, much of which is extracted in developing countries under conditions that frequently damage ecosystems and local livelihoods.
Valentina Lomanto, a Colombian lawyer-anthropologist, points to this directly: shifting the burden of renewable-energy hardware production onto developing countries can reproduce the very pattern that fossil-fuel extraction created — a clean-energy benefit in the consuming country and an environmental cost in the producing one. Read this way, SDG 7 is not delivered by hardware alone. It is delivered only when affordable and clean energy is paired with reductions in overconsumption (SDG 12) and with supply-chain rules that prevent renewable infrastructure from being built on the back of new ecological harm.
Conclusion
The picture of Scandinavian environmental success is not false, but it is incomplete. Per-capita emissions remain high, deforestation continues at meaningful rates, and the rare minerals required for the renewable transition are largely sourced elsewhere, often at significant ecological cost. Closing the gap between the image and the reality requires more than installing more clean-energy infrastructure: it requires engineers, indigenous communities, sustainability scientists and social scientists working together, and it requires recognising that the developed-country model of consumption cannot simply be extended to the rest of the world.
Reaching the goals set out in the 2030 Agenda will not come from sorting countries into “developed” and “developing” and asking the latter to follow the former; it will come from acknowledging that the consumption pattern of the former is itself a major part of what needs to change. The planet, after all, is a single system, and every state has a stake in how it is shared.
References
1. Encyclopædia Britannica, Norway — Economic Conditions. https://www.britannica.com/place/Norway/Economic-conditions
2. Norwegian Institute of Bioeconomy Research (NIBIO), Deforestation in Norway — c. 2.6 Mt CO₂ from deforestation in 2015; equivalent to roughly twice domestic air-traffic emissions. https://www.nibio.no/en/news/deforestation-in-norway
3. Lund University, Study uncovers widespread and ongoing clearcutting of Swedish old forests. https://www.lunduniversity.lu.se/article/study-uncovers-widespread-and-ongoing-clearcutting-swedish-old-forests
4. Our World in Data, CO₂ Emissions per Capita. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita
5. Luca Ventura, Poorest Countries in the World, Global Finance Magazine. https://gfmag.com/data/economic-data/poorest-country-in-the-world/
6. UNFCCC — Loss and Damage under Article 8 of the Paris Agreement and the Loss and Damage Fund (COP27). https://unfccc.int/topics/adaptation-and-resilience/workstreams/loss-and-damage-ld
7. Our World in Data, Energy Use per Person. https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/per-capita-energy-use
