Migration Without Borders: Why Global Cooperation Is Essential for Species Survival

Migratory species rely on habitats and protections that span multiple countries. The CMS, the only global treaty dedicated to their conservation, shows what international cooperation can achieve, but its work remains under-resourced and incomplete without political commitment from every state along a migratory range. Artwork by Sophie MC Gee.

By James Bonsal


This article argues that migratory species rely on habitats and protections spanning multiple countries, and thus, effective and adequately resourced international collaboration through the CMS is essential to prevent their decline and to preserve the ecosystems they sustain.

The urgency: extinction risk and the CMS’s role

Twenty-two per cent of CMS-listed migratory species are at risk of extinction, according to the first State of the World’s Migratory Species report published by UNEP and the CMS Secretariat in 2024.[1] Despite this, the Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals (CMS) remains the only global treaty dedicated to their conservation. It is an international framework agreement involving 130 countries and the European Union, supported by countless scientists and NGOs who identify migratory species at risk and work to protect them. This cooperation is essential because a bird may nest in Canada, overwinter in Brazil and pass through a dozen countries en route, defying any attempt at traditional, single-state conservation mechanisms.

Background: how the CMS began

This problem was recognised at the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment held in Stockholm in 1972,[2] which led to the adoption of the CMS in Bonn in 1979. The Convention entered into force on 1 November 1983, after fifteen states had deposited their instruments of ratification, as required by Article XVII.[3] Throughout the four decades of its existence, many more countries have joined as it expanded its reach across the globe, protecting migratory species wherever they travel.

An acrylic painting of a kingfisher perched on a bare branch, its back turquoise and blue and its breast orange, against a soft green background. The painting is photographed lying on a dark surface.
“Unique bird” by Sophie MC Gee

Why migratory species matter to ecosystems and the SDGs

Although other agreements encourage the protection of individual native species, many migratory species are key to the ecosystems they pass through. They provide essential services — pollinating plants, dispersing seeds, controlling pests and diseases, maintaining grasslands, and even helping to regulate marine and freshwater environments. Because they are not present at all times, instead spending large portions of their lives elsewhere, it is challenging to protect them effectively without global cooperation. Yet the number of migratory species is so great, and their influence on ecosystems so important, that without an effective mechanism of protection, SDGs 14 and 15 (Life Below Water and Life on Land) cannot be achieved, as many ecosystems will likely collapse without intervention.

Why migratory species matter for clean water (SDG 6)

The CMS framework intersects directly with SDG 6 (Clean Water and Sanitation). Many migratory species depend on intact freshwater systems — rivers, lakes, wetlands and the floodplains that connect them — for breeding, feeding and resting along their flyways. The CMS daughter agreement on African-Eurasian Migratory Waterbirds (AEWA), in force since 1999, addresses this dependence directly: it covers hundreds of bird species whose conservation status is bound up with the ecological condition of wetlands across multiple states.[4] When water bodies are polluted, drained or fragmented, migratory species lose stop-over sites and downstream human communities lose the water-quality services those ecosystems provide. Cross-border protection of freshwater habitats for migratory species is therefore not separate from the SDG 6 agenda — it is part of it.

How the CMS works: commitments and appendices

In order to join the CMS, a country must commit to preserving all migratory species listed in Appendix I by protecting and restoring their habitats. Parties must also remove obstacles to migration and conduct research on listed species to better understand their contributions to ecosystems, their conservation status, and the best methods of protection. The CMS additionally encourages international agreements specifically tailored to protect the species found in Appendix II, which, although threatened, are not at immediate risk of extinction.

Youth and public engagement

The CMS itself does not directly involve youth, but it frequently cooperates with NGOs at the national level. This opens up opportunities for young people to get involved — protecting their local species and making their voices heard on a global stage. The RSPB, for example, a charity which closely cooperates with the CMS to conserve migratory bird species, runs a youth council and a Network for Nature, involving young people in the fight to protect Britain’s birds. In addition, the CMS has a strong outreach programme, with events such as World Migratory Bird Day bringing the Convention’s work to a wider and younger audience.

Challenges: membership gaps, growing workload, and funding

Despite the tireless efforts of conservationists across the globe, an increasing number of animals are being threatened with extinction, including many migratory species whose routes take them through multiple countries, each of which must contribute to the animal’s protection. As more species are added to the appendices, the implementation burden on member states — to research, monitor and protect them — increases. New initiatives are constantly being formed and meetings held, addressing everything from bustards to snow leopards and bats.

Several major countries remain outside the Convention, including the United States, China, the Russian Federation and Canada. The reasons differ by state — ranging from constitutional and federal-jurisdiction concerns to economic and political considerations — but the absence of such large and biodiverse nations limits the geographic reach and influence of the CMS, making it harder to protect species whose ranges depend on those territories.

Funding is a further structural challenge. CMS Executive Secretary Amy Fraenkel has noted that an estimated USD 824 billion is required annually to protect and restore nature globally[5] — a figure that refers to the worldwide nature-finance gap, not the CMS’s own budget. Mobilising sums of this scale, across competing priorities and a political climate often hostile to conservation spending, remains one of the central obstacles to delivering on the Convention’s mandate.

Conclusion: shared responsibility and the path forward

The CMS has delivered tangible conservation outcomes. In Kazakhstan, coordinated international funding and anti-poaching enforcement helped the Saiga Antelope recover from roughly 20,000–30,000 individuals in the early 2000s to more than one million today[5] — a recovery that, in turn, restored landscapes that support water supply, vegetation balance and stop-over sites for migratory waterbirds. Yet the Convention faces severe challenges: a lack of funding and enforcement mechanisms, the absence of several powerful states from its membership, and an accelerating global biodiversity crisis that makes its work both harder and more urgent.

We must, as Amy Fraenkel says, “see the world through the eyes of a migrating bird or whale: no borders, only shared responsibility”.[1] The Convention continues to expand: Jamaica has signed the Convention — although it has not yet deposited an instrument of ratification, so the treaty has not yet entered into force for it — and new action groups are being added regularly. These are encouraging signs for the future of migratory-species conservation, but only if the political and financial commitment expands with them.


References

1. UNEP/CMS, “Landmark UN Report Reveals Shocking State of Wildlife: the World’s Migratory Species of Animals are in Decline, and the Global Extinction Risk Is Increasing”, press release on the State of the World’s Migratory Species, 12 February 2024. https://www.unep.org/news-and-stories/press-release/landmark-un-report-worlds-migratory-species-animals-are-decline-and

2. United Nations, Conference on the Human Environment, Stockholm, 5–16 June 1972. https://www.un.org/en/conferences/environment/stockholm1972

3. Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals (CMS) Secretariat, Frequently Asked Questions — entry into force, ratification thresholds and parties. https://www.cms.int/faq

4. Agreement on the Conservation of African-Eurasian Migratory Waterbirds (AEWA), CMS daughter agreement, in force since 1 November 1999. https://www.unep-aewa.org/

5. Amy Fraenkel (Executive Secretary, CMS), Message for World Wildlife Day — source for the USD 824 billion annual nature-finance estimate and the Saiga Antelope recovery in Kazakhstan. https://wildlifeday.org/en/message/amy-fraenkel-0

Leave a Reply